
By Randall Woodfin
A little more than 10 years ago, I announced my first run for mayor. As that anniversary passed, I’ve been thinking about how much our society has changed since then.
Back then, if I had told the people of Birmingham that one plus one equals two, I believe every person listening would have accepted it as true.
Today, if I say one plus one equals two, some people won’t believe it.
This isn’t unique to Birmingham. We’ve all heard the national conversation about misinformation, disinformation and foreign interference in our elections. We’ve watched public confidence collapse in nearly every institution that once anchored our shared life as a nation: government, religion, academia, the news media, the courts.
Maybe worse, we’ve lost faith in our neighbors. We look at the world as if everyone is selling something, and we’re skeptical of anyone who doesn’t tell us what we want to hear.
So when I say homicides in Birmingham are down 70% over the past two years, some people don’t believe it. They don’t take the time to look it up in the FBI Crime Data Explorer or check my math. They just say it isn’t true.
They won’t believe it when I say Birmingham City Schools has raised its state report card score from 72 to 77 in three years and cut its number of failing schools from 15 to one. That progress in a system with 43 schools belongs to a committed board, a dedicated superintendent in Dr. Mark Sullivan, and great staff at every level, and there’s more to come this year.
You don’t have to take my word for it. You can confirm every one of those numbers on the Alabama State Department of Education’s website.
But we now live in a world where we can pick information sources that let us skip the facts and simply confirm what we already believe, true or not.
This kind of distrust demands that our leaders act like leaders.
I recently spoke to the first class of graduates at the U.S. Coast Guard’s new home at Birmingham-Southern College. I also spoke at the Birmingham Police Department’s latest promotion ceremony, which celebrated one of the largest classes of new sergeants, lieutenants and captains we’ve ever had.
Every one of them now has a title that says “leader.” But a title doesn’t make you a leader.
What makes you a leader is how you carry yourself: whether you inspire confidence, promote excellence and uphold the values of the people you serve. Good leaders equip their teams to succeed, keep them moving in the right direction, and develop the leaders who will come after them. The best leaders have humility at their core. They accept that they won’t always be right and that they don’t know everything.
Leaders should listen more than they talk and keep learning. The funny thing is that the more you learn, the more you realize how little you know.
Now more than ever, our political leaders have a duty to cut through the noise, be intellectually honest and deal in facts, whether those facts are convenient or not.
I think of the late Sen. John McCain at a 2008 town hall, when one of his own supporters described his opponent, Barack Obama, as an outsider who couldn’t be trusted. McCain took the microphone and gently corrected her.
“No, ma’am,” he said. “He’s a decent family man, citizen, that I just happen to have disagreements with on fundamental issues, and that’s what this campaign is all about.”
McCain lost that election, and some strategists would say it proves that defending your opponent is bad politics. But McCain wasn’t defending his opponent. He was defending the truth. Real leaders don’t trade in falsehoods to win an argument or a race.
Years before he became our second president, John Adams took on the deeply unpopular job of defending British soldiers charged in the Boston Massacre. “Facts are stubborn things,” he told the jury, “and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passion, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence.”
That was true in 1770, and it’s true today. One plus one still equals two.
It’s time for leaders to take the higher road and take up the mantle of truth.
Randall L. Woodfin was sworn in as the 30th mayor of Birmingham, Alabama on Nov. 28, 2017 and is serving his third term. He continues to bring renewed vision, dedication and energy to a city where all residents have the opportunity to work, play and grow to their fullest potential. Mayor Woodfin’s goal is to uphold the Magic City’s legacy, making Birmingham a magnet for the next generation of purpose-driven builders who embrace innovation.
David Sher is the founder and publisher of ComebackTown. He’s past Chairman of the Birmingham Regional Chamber of Commerce (BBA), Operation New Birmingham (REV Birmingham), and the City Action Partnership (CAP).
Care about Birmingham, sign up for ComebackTown newsletter
Invite David to speak for free to your group about how we can have a more prosperous metro Birmingham. dsher@comebacktown.com





Well said Mayor. Indeed, truth and facts matter.
A problem that I identify is that with unlimited money that can be used in political campaigns–think Elon Musk’s recently announced additional $250 million in contributions–to distort truth and facts, we need to be vigilant in discerning facts from lies.
Yes, sir. Searching for and revealing TRUTH should be a core virtue for all of us…and especially so here in Birmingham and the South that are know for embracing Judeo-Christian principles.
Great column!
Thank you Sir. We are in a bad place in this country where basic facts are questioned daily and even those whose job it is to report facts are distrusted and discounted as liars and untrustworthy from the top levels of government. We fight lies with relentless truth telling. It will be a long fight but worth it for the salvation of our nation, our world, and our morality.
Strange article. When someone comes out pointing out all the good that has been accomplished, and facts back that up there is no need to question the integrity of the numbers.
My gut tells this has more to do with the Nebius land deal and the implication that his wife was somehow involved, rather than people not believing his numbers.
Mayor Woodfin is extremely thin skinned, and goes on social media rampages anytime his leadership is called into question.
Also, Mayor Woodfin had a CBS42 reporter fired (Lee Hedgepeth) for doing stories on the homeless population that Woodfin didn’t approve of.
I agree JJ, when a city council and a mayor restrict who can talk at meetings and are very secretive and will not discuss a potential problem, you can no longer trust them.
How were those leadership skills demonstrated in the Nebius deal? How are those leadership skills being demonstrated in the development(destruction) of the Nebius facility? I honestly believed Birmingham finally had a leader that would put the city, its occupants, & its needs first, Nebius has proven that to be false.
David Sher is a big Woodfin supporter and views him through rose colored glasses. Don’t expect to see any objective analysis of Woodfin’s shortcomings on this blog.
Expect more cheerleading and deflection anytime Woodfin’s name is mentioned. It’s unfortunate.
well, yeah…people are allowed to be supportive of who they choose. Sher is no different. But his work with this blog for years has been to give a voice for the better of Birmingham and to ask questions. i don’t always agree with his perspectives, but I think questioning his motives is a cheap shot.
Mayor Woodfin, is that you?
Who cares if David Sher is a Woodfin supporter. The fact of the matter is, Woodfin is the face of the city and reported on something positive that’s been happening. It’s one thing to hate on things that are deserving, but can’t you at least give nod to something good happening?
David, good for you for continuing this page in the face of idiotic comments directed at you.
Mayor Woodfin seems to be a caring, smart, successful Mayor. I believe he wants the folks in his city to be successful. I’d like to suggest Mayor Woodfin visit the website Action Coalition for Transit at alabamaact.org to learn why the Alabama doesn’t use our tax dollars to fund robust public transportation statewide. By the way, federal taxes we pay as citizens, help fund public transportation in the states that do provide bus service.
“I will only run for two terms” – Randall Woodfin, 2017
1+1=3 apparently.