Today’s guest columnist is Jay Taylor.
Three years.
That’s how long it’s been since the tumbleweed started rolling through Brookwood Village.
It seems longer, doesn’t it? Brookwood’s demise was slow and predictable.
We all saw it happen at Century Plaza, Eastwood, and other similar malls across the country, so we knew what was coming.
In its heyday, Brookwood was a destination that bustled with shoppers. But now, despite the mall’s closure, the real estate there remains fertile ground for retailers. Ask Target, Fresh Market, and other adjacent stores.
Still, I think we’ve all accepted that retail’s not coming back to the mall itself. So, what now? That’s been the question on the table since I don’t know when.
Personally, for years I’ve been pitching an ice rink in one of the department store spaces to anyone who would listen. A rink, in my view, would not only improve quality of life in central Alabama, it would bring in added tourism dollars to our state.
Finally, though, it looks like there’s movement with Brookwood.
Andrews Sports Medicine has big plans to transform the former Belk space into a $124 million surgery center.
In fact, the plan has been a mainstay on public meeting agendas in Homewood lately.
This makes the idea of a rink in the Macy’s space even better, and offers our city a golden opportunity to create something that may not exist anywhere else in the country: a sports venue in the same building as one of the nation’s premier sports medicine centers.
Imagine the possibilities.
Right now, Pelham has the only ice in central Alabama. The building features two rinks, and demand is high.
Pelham is home to the Birmingham Bulls, multiple men’s and women’s Alabama Frozen Tide teams, UAB hockey, youth travel hockey, youth house (rec) hockey, multiple adult hockey leagues, public skate, and figure skating.
And that doesn’t count all the extras like Try Hockey for Free as well as lessons for both hockey and figure skating.
The simple fact is, winter sports are growing in Alabama. Don’t be surprised if they build a rink on campus in Tuscaloosa in the not-too-distant future.
But moving Frozen Tide games over to the Druid City still won’t do enough to alleviate the need for more ice in the Birmingham area.
Why? Let’s talk about the dollars and cents.
You may not be a hockey parent like me, but if your kids have participated in travel sports, you know what happens when you hit the road for competition. Hotels. Restaurants. Shopping.
Hockey teams travel all over the continent for tournaments, and we do this year-round.
More ice at Brookwood Village doesn’t replace Pelham. It enhances that facility. The two venues can work together to host larger events on a frequent basis that will bring in out-of-towners.
Between games, parents can hit stores in the mall. They’ll venture elsewhere in the city before and after.
Locally, we can grow interest in and access to winter sports such as hockey, figure skating, and even curling. That’s right, curling. Adult leagues are all the rage in Huntsville.
The Brookwood rink should feature two sheets of ice with locker rooms and some bleacher seating on the ground level. On the second floor, there should be a restaurant/bar with a viewing area from above.
Not interested in winter sports? Well, a rink should serve the community too, with rental skates available for those who want to hit the ice just for fun.
Other cities turning defunct malls into ice rinks
But don’t take my word for any of this. Ask Nashville, Tulsa, Mason City, and other cities who have turned defunct malls into ice rinks. Better yet, ask John Zimmerman, the local figure skating legend and Homewood High School graduate.
Then ask yourself: how would you enjoy shopping during the holidays in a revived Brookwood Village, taking your kids to see Santa Claus, and going for a skate. What could be more appropriate for the season than that?
Remember, this isn’t a Homewood and Mt. Brook project alone. The entire metro area would benefit. I implore the leaders in our area to at least have a conversation about a rink at Brookwood.
It could be really cool.
Jay Taylor is a freelance writer based in Birmingham, Alabama. He has more than 30 years of experience working in advertising, journalism, marketing, and business. He renovated Kessler Lofts with his family and cofounded the startup TabX in Birmingham. Taylor previously served as president of the Central City Neighborhood Association. Today, he lives in Homewood with his wife and two children.
David Sher is the founder and publisher of ComebackTown. He’s past Chairman of the Birmingham Regional Chamber of Commerce (BBA), Operation New Birmingham (REV Birmingham), and the City Action Partnership (CAP).
Click here to sign up for our newsletter.
Invite David to speak for free to your group about how we can have a more prosperous metro Birmingham. dsher@comebacktown.com
Three years ago retired NFL quarterback and curling enthusiast Marc Bulger opened one of the first dedicated curling facilities in the South—located in a former metal processing plant a short distance from our house in a transitional West Nashville neighborhood. Tee Line has three curling sheets and has been a big success. We’ve given curling a try there and learned a few things about the sport. First, curling ain’t shuffleboard. “Throwing” the 40-lb stone is very difficult. Second, the ice is totally different from skating ice. Each curling sheet has millions of tiny frozen water droplets or “pebbles”, providing the right surface for the stone to travel, and it has to be perfectly level unlike skating ice. I don’t know how they curl on the rinks in Huntsville and elsewhere, but the surface probably isn’t suitable for serious competition. (Not that that would be an issue for a rink in Brookwood Mall.) Third, at the amateur league level, or for one-time amusement, drinking beer is a traditional part of curling. Thus Tee Line is a sports bar as well as a curling center, with televisions for viewing NFL and college football, bowling lanes, and an excellent menu for dining. I assume a liquor license and bar wouldn’t be a barrier to creating a successful ice rink in Brookwood. As for regular rinks in Nashville, one of two Ford Ice Rinks in the area is indeed located in the old Global Mall at the Crossings, which is undergoing complete renovation by the City.
Fantastic. Thinking outside the box! I hope that some creative developer will take up this idea.
Absolutely love this idea – Birmingham has long needed an ice rink in a more centrally located spot.
Jay and David, as an aspiring beer league hockey player, Birmingham resident, parent of two young kids and commercial real estate attorney, if there is anything I can do to help get this brilliant idea off the ground, please let me know.
A great idea for a local revitalization of. Brookwood Mall !!
The sports medicine facility will likely go in the former Belk building. An ice skating rink has been proposed in this article for the former Macy’s big box. I would like for a new use to be found for the part of the mall in between them.
How do we make this happen?
I’ve tried every possibility of making time to skate in Pelham (public skate, classes) but as a working mom in Birmingham, the drive is just too much
Wouldn’t it be nice to have some entertainment for us older people, like a gambling casino resort? I think that would bring in more revenue than anything else.
I know, Alabama has to protect its poor people from gambling. Maybe we could do it a little more upscale and give some of the profit to the poor people.
Great idea, a lot better than just sitting there. One point not made here is Eastwood and Brookwood created their own problems by lack of security and overpricing the rent for the stores.
I thought I had seen someone propose turning one of the old big box stores of Brookwood into a retirement village.