Time to rid ourselves of outdated one-way streets downtown

David Fleming,, President &CEO of REV Birmingham
David Fleming,, President & CEO of REV Birmingham

Today’s guest columnist is David Fleming.

Birmingham was founded in 1871 – well before the invention of cars and certainly before they were common.

However, the city’s core was built to support many different modes of transportation, including streetcars, horse and buggies, and trains.

Birmingham sits in Jones Valley, one of the few places in the world with all three ingredients needed to make iron and steel. This rare collection meant trains were in and out of Birmingham in its early days, and the city quickly boomed.

In fact, the Magic City earned its nickname because it magically grew overnight in the late 1800s, and the burgeoning steel industry meant the city’s new streets were designed to transport heavy material.

When the 20th century made automobiles plentiful and diminished the need for streetcars and trains, it meant more than changing cobble streets to pavement.

In 1973, the City of Birmingham managed a massive undertaking converting multiple downtown streets to one-ways to help alleviate traffic congestion.

The same year, the City’s Parking Authority was established to build the first of several major parking decks to accommodate cars for commuters.

Advocates for this change were well-intentioned and were responding to demand. The city center was perceived to be congested and slow moving, and people clamored to move faster through and out of downtown.

At the peak of the City of Birmingham’s population of over 340,000 residents in 1960, cities across the country were building big roads and parking lots to accommodate cars. The need for larger streets to carry more cars faster, especially downtown, has decreased since then. Sixty years later, the population of Birmingham is 200,133, according to the U.S. Census.

However, at the same time Birmingham was creating its one-ways, the city was also converting downtown’s main street, 20th Street, into the Birmingham Green. The linear park project with landscaped medians, larger sidewalks and two-way streets with no parking spaces reinforced the importance of 20th Street. Over the ensuing decades, 20th Street has retained the most overall vibrancy and pedestrian presence downtown.

REV supports a more vibrant and walkable downtown; that is what will stand the test of time.

One way to encourage that is by creating more comfortable spaces for pedestrians and increasing accessibility to different modes of transportation. How? Imagine a transition into two-way streets in downtown’s historic core:

  • Sidewalks could expand
  • Driving speeds would naturally slow
  • Additional space would allow for bike lanes, pocket parks and even more kinds of sidewalk cafes
  • Downtown surface parking lots could have higher and better uses as mixed-use developments.

Talk about added vibrancy! And we wouldn’t be the first to make such a change to increase vibrancy and safety.

Cedar Rapids, Iowa, is one of the many cities that have made the transition back to two-way streets. The city restored over 5 miles of streets to two-way travel. The reformation is a part of a much bigger effort to make the city center friendlier for pedestrians, motorists, bicyclists, and businesses.

Crime fell by 23% on the restored streets—compared to a 3% rise on the streets that did not change.

The researchers attribute the crime drop to better visibility from slower-moving, two-way traffic—one-way streets provide “shadow zones” between buildings where people can hide. The safer streets rose in value, providing more tax revenue to the city,” according to CNU journal.

Raleigh, North Carolina, is also following the trend and is underway with a two-way conversion project to one of their busiest roads. Their Complete Streets project strives to create safe travel in the city to accommodate all modes of transportation.

More and more U.S. cities are remaking their downtown street networks with the goal of improving the experience and enhancing vibrancy, and Birmingham should be among them.

Two-way streets in downtown Birmingham would boost economic growth, decrease crime, and enrich the downtown experience.

Every master plan that has been completed in Birmingham since the early 2000s has recommended the change to two-way streets.

Downtown Birmingham has more room for growth if we invest in our public realm now.

David Fleming is the President and CEO of REV Birmingham, a catalyst for downtown and neighborhood commercial district revitalization.  A native of the area, David lives with his wife and son in Crestwood.

David Sher is the founder and publisher of ComebackTown.  He’s past Chairman of the Birmingham Regional Chamber of Commerce (BBA), Operation New Birmingham (REV Birmingham), and the City Action Partnership (CAP).

Click here to sign up for our newsletter. (Opt out at any time)

Invite David to speak for free to your group about how we can have a more prosperous metro Birmingham. dsher@amsher.com.

(Visited 3,115 times, 1 visits today)

7 thoughts on “Time to rid ourselves of outdated one-way streets downtown”

  1. David, you are 100% correct. One-way streets carry traffic through the city center much faster than if they were two-way. That may have been a good idea decades ago, but today, auto traffic needs to slow because so many pedestrians, cyclists and scooters must share the streets. In addition, if autos come through the city going somewhere else, they should be shunted to roads outside the city center. In order for the city center to prosper, through traffic must be discouraged. I’ve been saying this for years. Now is the time to get rid of one-way streets through the city center.

  2. Continuing….fully agree with Mr. Fleming and Chervis! I say DO IT , if there is any hope it will REDUCE CRIME IN THE CITY! We are witnessing continued FLIGHT to the suburbs ….and making our CITY CENTER safer and more inviting should be PRIORITY ONE for everyone! Like it or not, DOWNTOWN is still the heart of our city… it cannot go down without a FIGHT!

  3. Thank you Mr. Flemming. My question is how can we, the citizenry, support you in this effort? What needs to be done? What would the next steps be? What would this cost and how can we compel those in power to undertake this transformation?

  4. I am not convinced by the argument to turn one-way streets into two-way streets. It is the width of the street, not the directions drivers are allowed to travel on it, that determines how much space there is for other modes of transportation on that street. One-way streets in effect create four-lane highways in downtown Birmingham when they are next to each other.

  5. Oh, David Fleming, good for you! We’ve both known for 40 years that Birmingham’s one-way streets are deadening, and now the spirit of the times seems to be catching up. Maybe the national obsession with cars and fast traffic is finally diminishing– it has dominated planning for way too long. Many cities figured this out years ago; I’m very glad that Birmingham is now on the verge of making such improvement of our street grid a reality.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *