Birmingham at mercy of outside interests

A sharecropper is someone who raises crops for the owner of a piece of land and is paid a portion of the money from the sale of the crops.

We in Birmingham have always been controlled by outside landlords.

Birmingham is the city of iron and steel and historically U.S. Steel controlled every aspect of our lives-politics, business, and people.  U.S. Steel is headquartered in Pittsburgh and was for much of Birmingham’s history our largest employer.  Birmingham’s labor was first to be laid off and last to be rehired.  All decisions favored Pittsburgh over Birmingham, and of course, all profits were sent up north.

Fortunately, U.S. Steel is no longer our largest employer, but unfortunately we are still being impacted. February 5th, U.S. Steel announced it could lay off up to 1,840 workers here.

But even though we are not now totally dependent on U.S. Steel, we are still controlled by outsiders.

Outside companies are buying up Birmingham

Birmingham companies are repeatedly being acquired by businesses headquartered out of state.

Fifteen years ago we had thirty public companies and six Fortune 500 Companies headquartered here.  Now we have 15 public companies and one Fortune 500 Company—Regions Financial.  Therefore many decisions that impact our region are made from out of state.

We’ve lost many of our major banks.  Recently we lost Colonial Properties Trust to Memphis, Protective Life to Japan, and the last of our major utilities, Alabama Gas, to the Laclede Group of St. Louis.  (AT&T and Southern Company–Atlanta).

Birmingham’s non-public companies are also targets of outside acquisition.  Sellers Richardson Holman & West, Integrated Medical Systems, All Seasons Travel, Riteway Service, Boatright Railroad Products, Ivan Leonard Chevrolet, and MedCenter Mazda are a few of our many companies who have been sold.

Montgomery controls Birmingham

And it’s not just business–it’s also government.  The capital of Alabama is Montgomery and our State government has never been kind to Birmingham. Thanks to politics in Montgomery, Birmingham was the last major city in the United States to complete our Interstate System.

And because of our outdated State Constitution, Jefferson County doesn’t have home rule–so most of our major financial decisions are decided by the Alabama State Legislature—not us.

UA Board of Trustees control UAB

Much of our media recently has been dominated by the loss of football at UAB and the University of Alabama Board of Trustees’ role in managing UAB.  There is much discussion about creating a separate BOT’s for UAB–or at least having proportional representation by UAB, but as of right now, decisions impacting UAB and Birmingham are made by the University of Alabama.

Outside interests control our future

We don’t have control of our own destiny–we look to Pittsburgh, Montgomery, or Tuscaloosa.

And what is our response?  We stay divided into our 35 separate municipalities and let outside landlords dictate our future.

The City of Birmingham is always left to fight alone

The City of Birmingham represents less than one third of Jefferson County and less than 20% of our metropolitan area—yet it is left alone to fight all our battles.  Whether it’s Railroad Park,  Regions Field, attracting the World Games, or fighting for Blazer Football, it’s always the City of Birmingham fighting alone.  Where are the Mayors and City Councils of Hoover, Homewood, Vestavia Hills, Mt. Brook or Trussville?

The solution:  A common vision for our region

If we are to stand up to cities like Nashville, Charlotte, or Austin, then we need to get out of our silos, create a common vision, and work together as one community.

Only then can we quit taking orders from outsiders and achieve our potential.

Let’s turn Birmingham around.  Click here to sign up for our newsletter.  There’s power in numbers. (Opt out at any time)

David Sher is the publisher of ComebackTown, a co-founder of Buzz12, a division of Intermark Group, and co-CEO of AmSher Compassionate Collections.  He’s past Chairman of the Birmingham Regional Chamber of Commerce (BBA), Operation New Birmingham (REV Birmingham), and the City Action Partnership (CAP).

(Visited 270 times, 1 visits today)

4 thoughts on “Birmingham at mercy of outside interests”

  1. *Most urban areas had a major university established in the late 1800’s or early 1900’s.  (Cincinatti, Louisville, Nashville, Charlotte, Atlanta etc.)  Birmingham was void of a major, urban university until 1969-the year UAB was no longer called an “extension center”.

    Birmingham, being without an institution like UAB. was deliberate and calculated. Powers locally and State wide did not want an advanced, urban university in Birmingham because of anti-urban fears ie a university brings in people who are “different” and educates the “wrong” type of people.

    That mentality still exists on the UA System BOT.


  2. A major problem is the continued support for Birmingham’s government owned and mismanaged schools.  School vouchers would eliminate the biggest impediment toward consolidation, but that would allow more individual freedom than we prefer in this land of the formerly free and home of the formerly brave.

  3. * Excellant   article.

    Start attending the Jefferson County Mayors Association meeting (35 mayors) and listen to the issues they deal with each day of the week.  Help them solve what they think think their problems are not what we know is one problem.  Thirty five cities in Jefferson County is a mess,but guess what so is consolidation by State Law.  I am told some cities in Jefferson County were consolidated into Birmingham in the 1930’s? Why oh why?

    Peace,George Munchus


  4. Great article.  The absolute truth, every bit of it! Alot of  us that have lived here have felt this was the case…Be careful doing impacting and insightful stories like this. Psychopaths with power might get mad at you..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *